Seismic Vulnerability and Damage Mechanisms of a Historic Masonry Complex: Numerical Assessment and Validation Against Observed Earthquake Damage
Abstract
The preservation of historic buildings that constitute an important part of the world’s cultural heritage requires reliable prediction of their structural behavior under seismic loading. In this study, the seismic behavior and structural vulnerability of the historic Amasya Çilehane Complex are investigated using finite element-based modal analysis, nonlinear static analysis, and nonlinear time-history simulations. The base-shear-to-weight ratio associated with the approximate onset of nonlinear response ranged from 0.23 to 0.46 for the selected ground motions. Although the calculated global drift ratios remained relatively low, the nonlinear analyses revealed localized tensile-strength exceedance and residual strain concentrations, particularly around façade openings, dome-support transition zones, and interior masonry walls. These results indicate that significant local damage may develop before substantial global deformation occurs. Comparison of the numerically identified critical regions with crack patterns documented in archival photographs showed notable spatial consistency, providing qualitative corroboration of the predicted damage mechanisms. Overall, the findings demonstrate the high seismic vulnerability of the complex and provide a rational basis for identifying critical structural regions and guiding future evaluations of conservation-compatible strengthening alternatives.

